People talk
Our Guestbook
“ They have the best pancakes! I eat breakfast here at least once a week. We always order the 300 breakfast, it’s more than enough for 2 and we always have leftovers too! ”
“ Definitely the best food in whitmore lake. We do carry out breakfast at least once a weekend, it’s always great! We also do carry out dinner quite often. Best coney dogs ever!!!!!! The girls are always sweet and efficient. ”
“ Really good breakfast! Very fair prices especially for the portions. Pancakes were above average for a coney. Nice people. Great experience. Will be returning often ”
“ We moved here in 2023 and ever since we come here at least once every weekend. I LOVE everything about this place! The breakfast is fantastic, the staff stay the same and are absolutely wonderful. However, I think what I love most is walking in picking a table and seeing all of the regulars eating, drinking coffee and talking. I love this small town and all that it brings with it! ”
“ Wendy is a very good server. Food was good and served in a timely manner. Nice old fashioned place. ”
“ Best breakfast I've had in ages. Highly recommend, will be back! ”
“ It was very good and a quick place to stop and get some food. I wish they had waffles here but the food was still good nonetheless ”
“ We heard about new ownership and said, "We have to go try it" and what an amazing experience. The food was all wonderful and getting to speak with the owners about the direction, feel and vision for the place was downright inspiring. With the thoughtful and sincere focus on community this location could spark a revitalization of Whitmore Lake in the area. Try it. Get to know people here. You won't regret it. --- Went again and Alyssa is an absolute joy as a server. I had the Big Poppa Breakfast with toast and potatoes as my included sides. ”
About
Whitmore Coney Island
Nestled in the charming Whitmore Lake, Michigan, Whitmore Coney Island has become a local treasure for food enthusiasts seeking hearty meals and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Located at 9457 Main St, this beloved eatery is known for its extensive breakfast menu and its signature dishes that keep patrons coming back week after week.
The heartbeat of Whitmore Coney Island lies in its breakfast offerings. Customer favorites like the 300 breakfast are a testament to the substantial portions and delightful flavors that await. As Toni Keywell shared in her glowing review, "They have the best pancakes!"—a sentiment echoed by many who savor the diverse breakfast options. The pancakes, touted as "above average for a coney," are fluffy and generously sized, making breakfast a truly satisfying experience.
But pancakes are just the beginning. Whitmore Coney Island also excels in lunch and dinner, particularly with its acclaimed coney dogs. As Helen Salisbury raved, “Best coney dogs ever!!!!!!” The coney dogs are not just a meal; they are an experience that embodies the spirit of the classic American diner.
The charm of this establishment transcends its menu. With warm smiles from the staff, like the attentive service provided by Wendy, every visit feels like coming home. As Dena Elliott expressed, visiting the restaurant, and mingling among fellow regulars, fosters a true sense of community. Walking in, you can instantly feel the nostalgic vibe of an old-fashioned diner where everyone knows your name.
- Location: 9457 Main St, Whitmore Lake, MI 48189
- Contact: +1 734-449-4405
- Cuisine Highlights: Breakfast, Coney Dogs, Pancakes
- Ambiance: Cozy, Friendly, Community-Oriented
Whitmore Coney Island isn’t just about food; it’s about community, comfort, and a collective joy for great meals. If you find yourself in Whitmore Lake, it’s truly a must-visit destination that promises both familiar faces and delicious plates. Whether you're a local or just passing through, the experience here at Whitmore Coney Island will leave you eagerly anticipating your next visit.
Book a table